Analysis of the Errors Committed by NPP MCR Operators during Implementation of Operating

UDC: 
621.039.58

Issue of journal:

Abstract: 

The present paper concentrates on the problem of errors committed by NPP MCR operators during implementation of operating procedures. It is proposed to categorize such errors into four classes as follows: selection of inappropriate procedure, incorrect execution of procedure, navigation errors, and communication errors. These categories of errors have been described and analyzed in detail in the paper. Each type of errors is illustrated by the real examples. The causes of the errors have been also investigated. It was revealed that a weaknesses of procedures is the main contributor to the committed errors. The following two aspects of two-column symptom-oriented procedures that impact on the operator activity were revealed: complicated logic which underlie the transition from the left column of procedure to the right one; and absence of tools for visual emphasis of procedure elements.

References: 
1. Chachko S.A. Predotvrashchenie oshibok operatorov na AES. Moscow, Energoatomizdat, 1992.
2. Reason J. Human error. New-York, Cambridge University Press,1990.
3. Suein A., Miller D. Oshibki cheloveka i ego nadezhnost'/V kn.: Chelovecheskii faktor (v 6-ti tomakh). Tom 1/ Pod red. G. Salvendi. Moscow, Mir, 1991, pp. 360-417.
4. Lee J., Park G., Sim B. Analysis of human errors in trip cases of Korean NPPs. Journal of the Korean Nuclear Society, 1996, vol. 28, no. 6, pp. 563-575.
5. Anokhin A.N. Analiz deyatel'nosti operatora: modeli i metody: Uchebnoe posobie. Obninsk, IATE, 1992.
6. Rasmussen J. Human errors: a taxonomy for describing human malfunction in industrial installations. Journal of Occupational Accidents, 1982, vol. 4, no. 2-4, pp. 311-335.
7. Gertman D., Blackman H., Marble J. et al. The SPAR-H human reliability analysis method (NUREG/CR-6883). Washington, D.C., US NRC, 2005.
8. Hollnagel E. Reliability Analysis and Operator Modeling. Reliability Engineering and System Safety. 1996, vol. 52, no. 3, pp. 327-337.
9. Periodic Safety Review of Nuclear Power Plant: Safety guide. Vienna, IAEA, 2003.
10. Holy Y. New emergency procedures of Westinghouse type form point of view of human factors and human reliability. Proceedings of the International Topical Meeting on Probabilistic Safety Assessment (PSA ’99) (Washington, D.C., August 22-26, 1999).
11. Barnes V., Haagensen B., OHara J. The human performance evaluation process: a resource for reviewing the identification and resolution of human performance problems (NUREG/CR-6751). Washington, D.C., US NRC, 2001.
12. Park J., Jung W. The operators non-compliance behavior to conduct emergency operating procedures – comparing with the complexity of the procedural steps. Journal of the Korean Nuclear Society, 2003, vol. 35, no. 5, pp. 412-425.
13. Rouse W., Rouse S. Analysis and classification of human error. IEEE Transactions on Systems, Man &Cybernetics, 1983, vol. SMC-13 (4), pp.539-549.
14. Derevyankin A.A. Issledovanie, razrabotka i primenenie metodov otsenki nadezhnosti personala pri provedenii veroyatnostnogo analiza bezopasnosti atomnykh stantsii. Dissertatsiya kand. tech. nauk. Moscow, 1991.
15. Gubinskii A.I. Nadezhnost' i kachestvo funktsionirovaniya ergaticheskikh sistem. Leningrad, Nauka, 1982.
16. Venda V.F. Sistemy gibridnogo intellekta: Evolyutsiya, psikhologiya, informatika. Moscow, Mashinostroenie, 1990, 448 p.
17. Anokhin A.N., Ostreikovskii V.A. Voprosy ergonomiki v yadernoi energetike. Moscow, Energoatomizdat, 2001, 344 p.
18. O’Hara J., Higgins J., Stubler W. Computerization of nuclear power plant emergency operating procedures (BNL-NUREG-67216). New-York, Brookhaven National Laboratory Upton, 2000.
19. Pleshakova N.V. Analiz primeneniya avariinykh protsedur operativnym personalom BShchU AS. Yadernye izmeritel'no-informatsionnye tekhnologii, 2012, no. 3 (43).
20. Forester J., Kolaczkowski A., Lois E. et al. Evaluation of human reliability analysis methods against good practices (NUREG-1842). Washington, D.C., US NRC, 2006.
21. Anokhin A.N., Pleshakova N.V., Chepurko V.A. Sistemnyi analiz ustnoi kommunikatsii mezhdu operatorami BShchU AES v avariinykh situatsiyakh. Izvestiya vuzov. Yadernaya energetika, 2009, no. 4, pp. 5-16.
22. Anokhin A.N., Pleshakova N.V., Maiorchikova M.S. Ergonomicheskaya otsenka i sistemnyi analiz protsedur dlya upravleniya energoblokom AES. Diagnostika i prognozirovanie sostoyaniya slozhnykh system. Sb. nauchn. tr. № 17 kafedry ASU pod red. d.t.n., prof. A.V. Antonova. Obninsk, IATE, 2007, pp. 68-77.

For full access to information log in or register here.